Discretionary Trusts

Gift and Inheritance Tax. Capital Acquisitions Tax. Dwelling House Exemption. CAT Reliefs and Exemptions

Everyone is aware that significant changes were introduced in the 2016 Budget but have you thought what they might mean for you?  From 25th December 2016, the Dwelling House Exemption from CAT (Capital Acquisitions Tax) will apply (i) to inheritances and (ii) gifts to a dependent relative.   Subject to certain exceptions, the inherited property must have been the principal place of residence of the deceased person at the date of death.  This requirement, however, will be relaxed in situations where the deceased person was required to leave their home, prior to the date of death, as a result of ill health.

Situation prior to 25th December 2016

Prior to 25^th December 2016, Section 86 CATCA 2003 provided a means of passing on a property to the next generation, either by gift or inheritance, in a tax free manner.

The exemption from Capital Acquisitions Tax for a gift or inheritance of a dwelling house or part of a dwelling house applied if the following conditions were met:

1. the donee/successor/beneficiary who received the gift or inheritance must have continuously occupied the dwelling house as their sole or main residence throughout a period of three years immediately up to the date of the benefit or
2. in circumstances where the dwelling house replaced another property, the donee/successor/beneficiary must have occupied the property as their only or main residence for a period of three out of the four years immediately before the date of the benefit  and
3. the donee/successor/beneficiary must not at the date of the gift/inheritance have been beneficially entitled to any other dwelling house or interest in any other dwelling house and
4. in circumstances where the donee/successor was aged under fifty five years, he/she must have continued to occupy the dwelling house as their sole or main residence for six years beginning on the date of the gift or inheritance.

Capital Acquisitions Tax Situation from 25^th December 2016

1. The Dwelling House Relief is available for inheritances of a dwelling house or part of a dwelling house only.  It is no longer available for gifts or gifts which convert to inheritances in circumstances where the donor dies within two years of the date of the gift.
2. The donor must have occupied the dwelling house as their sole or main residence at the date of his/her death. Please be aware that this requirement will be relaxed in situations where the deceased person could not remain in the dwelling house due to mental or physical infirmity. In other words if that individual requires specialist care in, say, a nursing home and as a result, has to leave their home, then they will be deemed to continue to occupy the property during that period.
3. The beneficiary/successor must have occupied the dwelling house as their sole or main residence for a continuous period of three years preceding the date of the inheritance. In other words, the house must be occupied by both the person making the gift at the date of death and the beneficiary receiving the gift at the date of the inheritance. Please be aware that this requirement does not apply in the case of a gift of a dwelling house to a “Dependant Relative.”
4.  The beneficiary/successor must not have an interest in any other dwelling house or part of a dwelling house at the date of the inheritance and
5.  The beneficiary/successor must continue to occupy the dwelling house as his/her main or sole residence for six years from the date of the inheritance.   Please be aware that this requirement will be relaxed in situations where the beneficiary/successor cannot remain in the dwelling house due to mental or physical infirmity or because the terms of their employment requires them to live elsewhere.
6.  The Dwelling House Relief will however be available on a gift of a dwelling house which is made to a “Dependant Relative.”   This is defined as a direct relative of the person making the gift or their spouse/ civil partner, and who is permanently and totally incapacitated by reason of mental or physical infirmity or is over the age of sixty five years.

What does this mean?

The amendment to Section 86 CATCA 2003 (Exemption relating to certain dwellings) has removed a valuable tax planning opportunity and will lead to unforeseen Capital Acquisitions Tax liabilities for individuals who receive gifts.

To most it seems like an excessive way of addressing the problem of wealthy families using this exemption as a means of transferring property to the next generation tax free.   For many families in Ireland the “Dwelling House Relief” was used by parents to help their children get on to the property ladder.   Some, however, welcome this amendment stating that it will ensure that family members who genuinely want to live with and care for elderly parents will inherit the family home tax free providing the conditions are met.

It is also important to keep in mind that since the conditions for this Relief are based on mental or physical infirmity then medical proof will be required to avoid a claw-back of the relief.

 In summary

1. Section 86 CATCA 2003 Dwelling House Relief is only available for inheritances unless a gift of a dwelling house is taken by a Dependant Relative who is permanently or totally incapacitated or aged over sixty five years.
2. The age at which a beneficiary/successor can take a property without being liable to the claw-back provisions has been increased from fifty five years to sixty six years.
3. The house must be occupied by both the disponer and the beneficiary at the date of the inheritance except where the property was gifted to a dependent relative.
4. The property is the only residential property that the beneficiary/successor is beneficially entitled to.

For further information, please click:

http://www.revenue.ie/en/practitioner/ebrief/2017/no-042017.html

For all your Irish or cross-border gift or inheritance concerns under Inheritance Tax, Gift Tax, Estate Tax and Capital Acquisitions Tax,  please contact us on queries@accountsadvicecentre.ie.

Please be aware that the information contained in this article is of a general nature.  It is not intended to address specific circumstances in relation to any individual or entity. All reasonable efforts have been made by Accounts Advice Centre to provide accurate and up-to-date information, however, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate on the date it is received or that it will continue to remain so. This information should not be acted upon without full and comprehensive, specialist professional tax advice.

Discretionary Trusts. Inheritance Tax. Gift Tax. Discretionary Trust Tax. Estate and Succession Planning.

Effective estate and succession planning enables you to tax efficiently transfer your assets, during your lifetime or at death, to your beneficiaries.  Trusts can play an important role in estate planning.   When setting up a Trust, it is essential to take into consideration the following tax heads: (i) Income Tax, (ii) Capital Gains Tax, (iii) Capital Acquisitions Tax, (iii) Stamp Duty and (iv) Discretionary Trust Tax.

INCOME TAX

The tax residence of the trustees is what determines the extent of their liability to Irish income tax.

If all the trustees are Irish resident then they are liable to Irish income tax on the worldwide income of the trust from all sources.

If, however, the trustees are resident in say France or the U.S. for tax purposes, then the trustees will only be liable to Irish income tax on Irish source income.

The Trustees must pay income tax at the standard rate of 20% on any income arising but they will not be entitled to claim any of tax credits, allowances or reliefs as they are not deemed to be individuals.

If the income of the trust has not been distributed within eighteen months from the end of the year of assessment in which the income has arisen, there will be a 20% surcharge on this accumulated income.

In circumstances where a beneficiary has an absolute right or entitlement to the trust income as opposed to the Trustees then Revenue will assess the beneficiary directly.  In other words if the terms of the trust state that income is to be paid directly to a particular beneficiary as opposed to the trust then the beneficiary will be liable to Income Tax on the amounts received.  That individual must file the appropriate tax return and pay the relevant taxes within the deadline dates.

CAPITAL GAINS TAX

For the purposes of CGT, the trustees will to be Irish resident and ordinarily resident if the general administration of the trust is carried out in Ireland and if all or the majority of the trustees are resident or ordinarily resident in Ireland.

In general, if the trustees are resident or ordinarily resident in Ireland they will be liable to Irish capital gains tax on their worldwide gains.

If, however, the trustees are not resident or ordinarily resident in Ireland they will be liable to Irish capital gains tax in respect of any gains arising on disposal of specified assets including:

• Land and buildings in Ireland .
• Minerals in Ireland including related rights, and exploration or exploitation rights in a designated area of the continental shelf.
• Unquoted shares deriving their value, or the greater part of their value, from such assets as mentioned above.

Please keep in mind that, just as for Income Tax purposes, the trustees are not deemed to be individuals and are therefore not entitled to the annual CGT exemption of €1,270 which is only available to individuals.

Apart from selling/distributing the trust assets, the trustees will be deemed to have disposed of assets for CGT purposes in the following three situations:

1. Where the trustees cease to be Irish resident or ordinarily resident.
2. Where a life interest in the trust property has ended but the property continues to be settled property.
3. Where a beneficiary becomes absolutely entitled in possession to the settled property except in situations where it occurred as a result of the death of the individual with a life interest in that property.

Market Value rules are imposed on this event with the Trustees being deemed to have disposed of and immediately reacquired the property at open market value.  As with all CGT computations, the liability is calculated on the difference between its base cost and the deemed market value.

CAPITAL ACQUISITION TAX

Capital Acquisition Tax is only payable when the beneficiary actually receives a gift or inheritance.  Where a beneficiary receives the gift/inheritance under a deed of appointment from a trust then he/she/they will be taxed as if the benefit was received from the settlor/testator.

Capital Acquisition Tax at 33% is payable by the beneficiary and is charged on the value of the gift or inheritance to the extent that it exceeds the relevant tax-free threshold amount.

A charge to Irish Capital Acquisition Tax will arise in the following situations:

• If the beneficiary is Irish resident or ordinarily resident on the date he/she/they receives the benefit.
• If the settlor is Irish resident or ordinarily resident either (a) at the date of setting up the trust or (b) on the date the beneficiary receives the benefit.
• In circumstances where the settlor is Irish resident or ordinarily resident at the date of his/her/their death a liability to Irish CAT will arise on any benefit taken on the settlor’s death
• Where the property, which comprised the benefit, is situated in Ireland.

Points to keep in mind

• The creation of a discretionary trust or the transfer of funds to a discretionary trust will not give rise to a charge to capital acquisitions tax.
• Distributions from a trust, however, can potentially give rise to both an Income Tax and a Capital Acquisitions Tax liability. You’re probably asking yourself if a double charge to tax has arisen.  It has.  Regular or periodic distributions to a beneficiary will be subject to the individual’s marginal rate of Income Tax but can also, at the same time, be liable to CAT.  A Revenue concession exists where CAT is chargeable on the net benefit i.e. the benefit after Income Tax has been deducted.  Don’t forget, the small gift exemption of €3,000 per annum can also be deducted.

STAMP DUTY

Stamp Duty can arise on the transfer of assets into a trust at 1% in the event of shares, residential property valued at less than one million euros, etc. or 2% in the event of commercial property, business assets, etc.

There is no Stamp Duty on the transfer of assets into a trust that is created by a Will.

Where trust assets are appointed by the Trustees to the beneficiaries then no Stamp Duty charge will arise i.e. there is an exemption from Stamp Duty in this situation.

DISCRETIONARY TRUST TAX

Discretionary trust tax of 6% is a once off charge based on the value of assets comprised in a discretionary trust.

If the Trust is wound up and all the assets are appointed within a five year period then 50% of this initial charge will be refunded i.e. 3%

The initial charge is due and payable on the later of the following dates:

• The death of the settlor or
• Where the last of the “principal objects” (i.e. spouse, child or child of a predeceased child of the Disponer) has reached his/her 21st birthday.

A 1% annual charge on undistributed assets comprised in a discretionary trust will arise every year on 31st December.  This annual levy, however, will not arise within the same twelve month period as the initial charge of 6% has been levied.

For further information, please click:

https://www.revenue.ie/en/tax-professionals/tdm/capital-acquisitions-tax/cat-part05.pdf

https://www.revenue.ie/en/gains-gifts-and-inheritance/discretionary-trust-tax/initial-once-off-6-charge.aspx

https://www.revenue.ie/en/tax-professionals/tdm/income-tax-capital-gains-tax-corporation-tax/part-19/19-03-03.pdf

Please be aware that the information contained in this article is of a general nature.  It is not intended to address specific circumstances in relation to any individual or entity. All reasonable efforts have been made by Accounts Advice Centre to provide accurate and up-to-date information, however, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate on the date it is received or that it will continue to remain so. This information should not be acted upon without full and comprehensive, specialist professional tax advice.